Topic 21 of 64· Social value and impact measurement
Social Value Act
The Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 is a UK statutory duty requiring public authorities in England and Wales to consider how what is being procured might improve the economic, social, and environmental wellbeing of the relevant area, and to consider consulting on this, before starting a procurement process for public services contracts. It came into force in January 2013 as a relatively light-touch "have regard to" duty, and was substantially strengthened by Procurement Policy Note (PPN) 06/20 in January 2021, which requires central government contracts to explicitly evaluate — not merely consider — social value, with a minimum weighting in the award criteria.
Why it matters
Before PPN 06/20, "considering" social value could be satisfied by a commissioner noting they had thought about it, with no requirement that it affect the award decision — a duty easy to discharge on paper and ignore in practice. PPN 06/20 closed that gap for central government procurement: it mandates social value be scored as part of the tender evaluation, organised around five national priority themes — COVID-19 recovery, tackling economic inequality, fighting climate change, equal opportunity, and wellbeing — and commonly measured using the National TOMs (Themes, Outcomes, Measures) framework maintained by the Social Value Portal. For a software engineer building procurement, contract management, or bid-support tools for the public sector, this is the legal basis your client is required to build against, not an optional nice-to-have.
The maths
Social value is a framework-shaped topic; its "maths" is the scoring structure most authorities use:
Total tender score = Price/cost weighting + Quality weighting + Social value weighting
PPN 06/20 (central government): social value weighting ≥ 10% of total score
Social value themes (PPN 06/20):
1. COVID-19 recovery
2. Tackling economic inequality
3. Fighting climate change
4. Equal opportunity
5. Wellbeing
Bidders typically monetise their commitments against these themes using unit cost databases, and the same monetisation logic used in social return on investment applies: a commitment should be evidenced, attributable to the contract, and not double-counted against other funding.
Worked example
Local authority IT contract: a £2 million, 3-year contract is scored 60% quality, 30% price, 10% social value. Bidder A commits to 2 apprenticeships, £150,000 of local subcontracting spend, and 200 hours of pro bono digital-skills training for a local school, monetised using proxies from a unit cost database at a combined £90,000 of additional social value. Bidder B commits to a smaller package monetised at £40,000. If the authority scores social value proportionally against the strongest bid, Bidder A receives the full 10 points; Bidder B receives 10 × (£40,000 ÷ £90,000) = 4.4 points — a 5.6-point gap that can decide the contract even where quality and price are close.
Voluntary sector bidder: a small VCSE (voluntary, community and social enterprise) bidding for a grounds maintenance contract against a commercial competitor cannot compete on unit price alone, but uses Global Value Exchange proxies to monetise its existing community employment and volunteering commitments, making an evidenced social value case worth scoring alongside price and quality.
Software engineering connection
Winning a bid with monetised social value commitments creates an obligation to evidence delivery against them through contract management — tools that log apprenticeship starts, local spend, and training hours against the specific commitments scored at tender, feeding into contract review meetings rather than being forgotten once the contract is signed. G-Cloud and Digital Marketplace listings increasingly require social value statements at the point of listing. See social return on investment for the valuation method behind the commitments, unit cost databases for the proxies bidders draw on, and outcomes vs outputs for making sure delivered commitments are outcomes, not just activity counts.
Pitfalls
- Social-washing bids. Vague commitments ("we support the local community") that cannot be measured or held to during contract management score well but deliver nothing verifiable.
- Treating social value as a tie-breaker. PPN 06/20 requires social value to be explicitly evaluated within the award criteria, not used informally to break a tie between otherwise equal bids.
- No contract management follow-through. Commitments scored at tender are frequently never tracked during delivery — see benefits realisation.
- Inconsistent measurement frameworks across contracts. Using different proxy sources for similar commitments on different contracts makes portfolio-level comparison meaningless, which is why common frameworks like National TOMs and shared unit cost databases exist.
Sources
- Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2012/3/contents
- Cabinet Office, Procurement Policy Note 06/20, "Taking Account of Social Value in the Award of Central Government Contracts." https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/procurement-policy-note-0620-taking-account-of-social-value-in-the-award-of-central-government-contracts
- Social Value Portal, National TOMs Framework. https://socialvalueportal.com/national-toms/