Topic 16 of 64· Governmental economic appraisal
Shadow Pricing
A shadow price is an estimated value assigned to a good, resource, or externality that has no observable market price, or whose market price is distorted and does not reflect its true social value. Government appraisal relies on a small set of official shadow prices — carbon, non-work time, unemployed labor — published centrally so every department uses the same number.
Why it matters
Shadow prices exist because social cost-benefit analysis cannot function without a monetary value for every cost and benefit, and several of the most consequential ones — a tonne of carbon emitted, an hour of a commuter's time, an hour of otherwise unemployed labor — have no market price at all, or a market price that misrepresents their true social cost. HM Treasury and the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero jointly publish the shadow price of carbon used across all UK government appraisal (https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/valuing-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-policy-appraisal), derived not from any carbon market price but from a target-consistent approach: the carbon value is set at the marginal abatement cost needed to hit the UK's legislated carbon budgets, which is a fundamentally different logic from observing what carbon actually trades for on the EU or UK Emissions Trading Scheme.
The shadow wage rate follows a similar logic on the labor side. Employing someone who would otherwise have been unemployed does not cost society their full wage — part of that wage is a transfer from foregone benefits payments and lost leisure/search time rather than a net new draw on society's resources — so Green Book guidance sets a shadow price below the market wage for labor drawn from unemployment, reflecting the true opportunity cost of that labor (see opportunity cost in public spending) rather than its market price.
The math
Shadow price of carbon (illustrative structure, current values from the
official BEIS/DESNZ carbon values tool — do not use stale figures):
Traded sector value: informed by ETS allowance price trajectories
Non-traded sector (target-consistent) value: set to the marginal cost
of abatement needed to meet legislated carbon budgets, rising over
time as easier abatement options are exhausted
Applied as: £/tonne CO2e × tonnes emitted or abated by the option,
discounted at the social discount rate for future years
Shadow wage rate (SWR):
SWR = Market wage − (value of foregone leisure/search time saved
+ value of welfare payments no longer paid)
Typically expressed as a fraction of the market wage (e.g. SWR = 0.6
× market wage in a high-unemployment area, per Green Book Annex A
guidance on labor markets with spare capacity)
Both figures are policy conventions set centrally, not empirical market observations — the whole point of a shadow price is to substitute for a missing or distorted market, so an appraisal using one must cite the current official source rather than deriving its own figure, precisely so every department's appraisal is comparable.
Worked example
National government: a flood defense scheme appraisal estimates it avoids 400 tonnes of CO2e emissions per year (through reduced use of emergency plant and reduced embodied carbon from avoided reconstruction) over a 30-year appraisal life, compared against a "do minimum" baseline.
Illustrative shadow price of carbon: £280/tonne CO2e (year 1, rising over
the appraisal period per the official non-traded carbon values schedule)
Year 1 carbon benefit = 400 × £280 = £112,000
Because the official schedule has the carbon value rising over the appraisal period (reflecting tightening carbon budgets), the analyst must apply the correct year-specific value for each year of the 30-year stream, not a flat rate — using the year 1 value throughout would understate later-year benefits and distort the ranking against alternative flood defense designs with different carbon profiles.
Local authority: a council's employment support program for long-term unemployed residents places 150 people into jobs paying £11/hour. Valuing this using the full market wage would credit the program with £11 × hours worked as a social benefit, but the shadow wage rate approach recognizes that these were not workers drawn from other jobs — the true opportunity cost of their labor before the program was low.
Market wage: £11.00/hour
Shadow wage rate (illustrative, high local unemployment): 0.6 × market wage = £6.60/hour
Net social benefit attributable per hour worked ≈ £11.00 − £6.60 = £4.40/hour
(the "extra" value created by moving genuinely idle labor into production,
as distinct from the wage itself, which is largely a transfer)
This is why appraisals of employment programs in high-unemployment areas can show a positive net social value even when the same program, run in a full-employment area where displaced labor would simply be drawn from other jobs, would not.
Software engineering connection
Shadow pricing rarely touches software delivery directly, but it matters whenever a business case claims a carbon or social benefit from an IT change — a data-center consolidation claiming carbon savings, or a paperless-service claiming avoided printing and postage carbon, must use the current official shadow price of carbon rather than an invented figure, and must apply the correct year-by-year schedule rather than a flat rate, exactly as with any other Green Book appraisal input. See total cost of ownership in government IT and public sector cybersecurity value, both of which often need a shadow price for a hard-to-monetize input (breach risk, downtime) alongside directly costed items.
Pitfalls
- Using a stale carbon or wage figure. Both values are revised periodically by central guidance; an appraisal built on a superseded figure will not survive Treasury scrutiny.
- Applying a flat shadow carbon price across a multi-decade appraisal. The official schedule rises over time; using year 1's value throughout misstates the profile of benefits or costs.
- Confusing the shadow wage with a discount on the worker's actual pay. The shadow wage rate adjusts the appraisal's valuation of the labor input, not the wage the worker is actually paid — conflating the two invites (incorrectly) justifying below-market pay.
- Deriving a bespoke shadow price instead of using the official one. Shadow prices are policy conventions precisely so appraisals are comparable across departments; a locally invented figure, however well-reasoned, breaks that comparability.
Sources
- HM Treasury / Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. "Valuing greenhouse gas emissions in policy appraisal." https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/valuing-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-policy-appraisal
- HM Treasury. "The Green Book: appraisal and evaluation in central government," Annex A (shadow price of labor, non-work time values). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-central-government
- Little IMD, Mirrlees JA. "Project Appraisal and Planning for Developing Countries." Heinemann, 1974 (foundational shadow-pricing methodology).