Batu na 43 cikin 64· Ƙimar jama'a a gwamnatin dijital
Tanadin Sauya Hanyar Hidima (Channel Shift)
Tanadin sauya hanyar hidima (channel shift) shi ne raguwar kuɗi da aka hasashe daga motsa yawan ma'amaloli daga hanyoyi masu tsada — waya, kantunan fuska-da-fuska, wasiƙar takarda — zuwa hidimar kai ta dijital mai arha. Shi ne injin kuɗi na bayan "digital by default", kuma shi ma layin da yafi yiwuwa ya yi kuskure a shawarar kasuwanci, domin zatonsa — cewa hanyoyin da ba na intanet ba suna raguwa yayin da karɓar dijital ke ƙaruwa — yana gaskiya a wasu lokuta kawai.
Dalilin da ya sa yake da muhimmanci
Lissafin yana kama da wanda ba za a iya ƙin yarda da shi ba idan aka yi amfani da lambobin kuɗin kowace ma'amala daga Digital Efficiency Report: a motsa ma'amaloli miliyan ɗaya daga ziyarar fuska-da-fuska ta £8.62 zuwa ta dijital ta £0.15 kuma tanadin ya wuce £8 miliyan. Amma tanadi yana zama kuɗin da aka saki don sake rarrabawa ne kawai idan ƙarfin ƙayyadadde na hanyar da ke raguwa an soke shi da gaske — kujerun cibiyar kira, ma'aikatan kanti, mintunan kwangilar waya — kuma shirye-shiryen dijital na ƙananan hukumomi sun sha gano cewa jimillar yawan tuntuɓa ba ya raguwa daidai da karɓar dijital. Bincike daga shirye-shiryen sauyin dijital na ƙananan hukumomi da hukumomi irin su Socitm da Local Government Association ya rubuta wani tsari da ke maimaituwa: hanyoyin dijital suna jawo sabuwar tuntuɓa ta gaske (ƴan ƙasa da ba za su kira ko ziyarta ba yanzu suna yi, saboda ya fi sauƙi), kuma wani kaso mai ma'ana na ma'amaloli "na dijital" suna kasawa a tsakiya kuma suna haifar da kiran waya ko ta yaya — don haka yawan waya yana raguwa da ƙasa da yadda kashi na karɓar dijital zai nuna, wani lokaci ba ya raguwa kwata-kwata a cikakken adadi ko da kasonsa na jimillar tuntuɓa yana raguwa.
Lissafi
Tanadin sauya hanya na gaba ɗaya = yawan da aka motsa × (kuɗin_tsohuwar_hanya − kuɗin_dijital)
Tanadi na gaske (wanda aka cimma) = tanadin gaba ɗaya
− sabuwar buƙata/buƙatar inuwa da hanya mai sauƙi ta ƙirƙira
− kuɗin buƙatar gazawa (gazawar dijital da
har yanzu ke haifar da kiran waya ko ziyarar kanti)
− kuɗin ƙarfin ƙayyadadde da ba a soke ba (cibiyar
kira za ta iya rage ma'aikata ne kawai a rukuni-rukuni;
raguwar yawa ta 15% da wuya ta bar a yanke 15% na
adadin ma'aikata)
Iyakar cimmawa: tanadi yana iya ajiyewa ne kawai idan yawan ya faɗi
ƙasa da matakin da tsohuwar hanyar za ta iya ɗaukar ma'aikata a mataki na gaba
mafi ƙanƙanta na ƙarfi (misali rasa cikakken lokacin aiki ɗaya, tebur
ɗaya cikakke, rukunin ma'aikaci ɗaya na kwangila)
Misali aiki
Hidimar sabunta katin shuɗi (blue badge) ta majalisar gundumar: sabuntawa 60,000/shekara, a baya 100% ta waya/takarda a £6.40 kowace ma'amala. Sabuwar hidimar dijital ta fara kuma ta kai karɓar dijital 65% cikin shekara, a £0.30 kowace ma'amalar dijital.
Lissafin tanadi mai sauƙi (na gaba ɗaya):
39,000 da aka motsa × (£6.40 − £0.30) = £237,900/shekara
Abin da ya faru da gaske, bisa bayanan cibiyar tuntuɓa ta majalisa:
Yawan waya ya faɗi daga 60,000/shekara zuwa 46,000/shekara (−23%, ba −65% ba)
saboda: tafiye-tafiyen dijital 9,000 sun kasa kuma sun haifar da kiran biyo baya
(zubar buƙatar gazawa), kuma mutane 4,000 da a baya ba su sabunta ba
kwata-kwata yanzu suna yi, bayan sun same shi mai sauƙi a intanet
(buƙatar inuwa — ingantaccen samun hidima na gaske, amma ba tanadi ba)
Cibiyar kiran waya tana da ma'aikata a rukunin kira 8,000/FTE;
raguwar kira 14,000 (60,000 → 46,000) tana 'yanta 1.75 FTE, wanda a aikace
an rage zuwa 1 FTE da aka sake raba da gaske = £34,000/shekara
Tanadin da aka cimma = £34,000/shekara tare da kuɗin ginawa/gudanar da
hanyar dijital da aka kauce wa a kan ma'amaloli 39,000 ≈ £34,000 + (39,000 × £0.30
kuɗin dijital da aka riga aka ƙidaya) — ɗan kaɗan na babban lambar £237,900,
duk da cewa hidimar tana da kyau ga masu amfani ba tare da shakka ba.
Alaƙa da injiniyancin manhaja
Darasin injiniya shi ne cewa tanadin sauya hanya ana cimma shi ne ta shawarwarin aiki (tsara jadawalin aiki, soke ƙarfi, sake yin shawarwarin kwangila), ba ta fitar da manhajar ba — ƙungiya na iya cika kowane batu na ma'aunin hidimar dijital kuma har yanzu ta isar da tanadi sifili idan babu wanda ya soke ƙarfin ƙayyadadden tsohuwar hanyar. Auna buƙatar gazawa (a ina a tafiyar dijital masu amfani ke barin da abin da suke yi bayan haka) matsalar nazarin funnel ce da za a iya warwarewa kuma shi ne abu mafi tasiri da ƙungiyar injiniya za ta iya yi don kare shari'ar tanadi; shi ma hanyar haɗi ce kai-tsaye da kuɗin kowace ma'amala, wadda buƙatar gazawa ke ƙara girmanta a ɓoye. Duba cimma fa'idodi don faɗaɗaɗɗen horon duba cewa tanadin shawarar kasuwanci yana sauka da gaske, da haɗa kowa da dijital don dalilin da ya sa hanyar da ba ta intanet ba yawanci ba za a iya, kuma bai kamata a, soke ta gaba ɗaya ba.
Tarkuna
- Zaton maye gurbin hanya 1:1: ƙirƙirar karɓar dijital a matsayin ragewa kai tsaye daga yawan waya/kanti, tare da yin watsi da buƙatar inuwa da zubar buƙatar gazawa da aka rubuta a binciken sauya hanya na gwamnatin gida.
- Rubuta tanadi na gaba ɗaya kafin soke ƙarfi: ƙidaya tanadin a shawarar kasuwanci a shekarar da karɓa ke ƙaruwa, ba a shekarar (idan har ta taɓa zuwa) da aka yanke ƙarfin tsohuwar hanyar ba.
- Yin watsi da yanayin matakin kuɗin ma'aikata: raguwar yawa ta 20% da wuya ta koma raguwar kuɗi ta 20%, domin cibiyoyin tuntuɓa da kantuna ana ɗaukar ma'aikata a rukunai, ba ci gaba ba.
- Ɗaukar buƙatar inuwa a matsayin ɓarna: sabuwar tuntuɓa daga masu amfani da a baya aka cire ko aka hana su ƙaruwa ce ta gaske a ƙimar jama'a, ba kuskuren ƙira ba — ya kamata a ba da rahotonta a matsayin sakamakon samun hidima, ba a cire ta kamar hayaniya ba.
Majiyoyi
- Cabinet Office, Digital Efficiency Report (2012). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/digital-efficiency-report/digital-efficiency-report
- Local Government Association, digital transformation and channel shift resources. https://www.local.gov.uk/our-support/efficiency-and-income-generation/digital-transformation
- Socitm, local public services digital insight research. https://www.socitm.net/