Topic 57 o 64· Saftware engineerin an digital delivery connection
Cost o Delay in Public Programmes (CoD)
Cost o Delay is the public value lost per unit time that a programme, service, or system chynge is no yet delivert. It is the maister brig metric o this group o topics: it converts "the go-live slippit six months" intae pounds per week, or intae WELLBYs per week, sae that delay can be argued aboot in the same currency as the business case itsel.
Why it maitters
Reinertsen's rule — "if ye anely quantify ae thing, quantify the Cost of Delay" — travels intae government near unchynged, acause public programmes are unco exposed tae it: business cases are approved against a forecast benefit stream, but the stream anely stairts flowin at go-live, an ilka week o slippage is a week o forgane value that naebody prices on the risk register. The National Audit Office's repeatit scrutiny o Universal Credit's rollout (see its "Rolling Out Universal Credit" reports, https://www.nao.org.uk/) illustrates the pattern: schedule slippage wis trackit an reportit, but the pounds-per-week cost o no yet deliverin the reformit system tae the next tranche o claimants wis seldom statit as a headline figure, even though it's the nummer that shuid hae driven prioritization an escalation. Athoot a CoD figure, a delayed programme looks like a schedule problem for the delivery board; wi ane, it's a value-erosion problem for the accountin officer.
The maths
CoD = benefit per unit time forgane while undelivert (£/week or WELLBYs/week)
Total delay loss = CoD × delay duration
Benefit streams tae sum for public programmes:
cash-releasin savings (fraud/error reduction, avoidit temporary costs)
+ non-cash capacity freed (caseworker/officer oors × loadit cost)
+ wellbein benefit (WELLBYs × £13,000/WELLBY, HMT Green Book
wellbein supplementary guidance, 2019 prices)
For citizen-facin services, denominate in wellbein as weel as siller — see wellbeing-adjusted life years for the unnerlyin unit, an opportunity cost in public spending for whit the delayed pound could itherwise hae fundit.
Wrocht example
Local authority: a hoosin-benefit system upgrade cuts owerpayment error by £150/claim/year athort 20,000 live claims.
Annual benefit = 150 × 20,000 = £3,000,000/year
CoD = 3,000,000 / 52 ≈ £57,700/week
A 12-month implementation delay costs 52 × 57,700 ≈ £3,000,000 in avoidable error.
Central government agency: a disability-benefit assessment service, delivert six months (26 weeks) later than plannit, means 200,000 claimants/year wait an average three weeks langer for a decision. Ilka extra week o financial uncertainty is modellit as a −0.0018 WELLBY (life-satisfaction pynt) effect:
WELLBY loss per claimant = 3 × 0.0018 = 0.0054
Annual WELLBY loss = 200,000 × 0.0054 = 1,080 WELLBYs/year
CoD_wellbein = 1,080 / 52 ≈ 20.8 WELLBYs/week
CoD_siller = 20.8 × £13,000 ≈ £270,000/week o wellbein value
A 26-week delay therefore "costs" roughly 540 WELLBYs — worth aboot £7 million at the Green Book's wellbein valuation — reframin a missed go-live date as a citizen-welfare event, no a project-management fitnote.
Link tae saftware ingineerin
CoD is whit maks DORA metrics an flow metrics financially legible: lead time in the pipeline × CoD is siller (or wellbein) burnt in queues afore it iver reaches a citizen. Concretely:
- Prioritization: rank a backlog by CoD ÷ duration raither than by stakeholder seniority — the software engineerin analogue o the Green Book's requirement tae appraise options on value, no on wha's askin.
- Procurement: a 12–18 month framework procurement cycle haes a CoD; pricin it chynges the urgency case for accelerated routes, an feeds straucht intae build vs buy decisions whaur time-tae-value is a decision driver.
- Benefits case: ilka CoD figure quotit at approval shuid appear again at benefits realization — if the delay cost wis real, the accelerated benefit shuid be meisurable efter go-live.
Pitfaws
- Assumin linear CoD: some public services hae deadline-shapit value (a statutory compliance date — CoD jumps tae enforcement-risk levels efter the date, near zero afore) raither than a smooth weekly rate. Classify the urgency profile afore multiplyin.
- CoD on ootputs naebody needs: delay anely haes a cost if the undelivert thing haes value; a system naebody will uise haes zero CoD nae maitter hoo late it is.
- Double-coontin delay an discountin: the social discount rate awready prices time on multi-year appraisal horizons; CoD is the within-horizon, operational version for weeks an months. Uise CoD for schedule slippage, NPV shift for multi-year re-phasin.
Sources
- Reinertsen DG, The Principles of Product Development Flow, Celeritas Publishing, 2009.
- HM Treasury, Green Book supplementary guidance: wellbeing. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/green-book-supplementary-guidance-wellbeing
- National Audit Office, reports on Universal Credit rollout. https://www.nao.org.uk/