Topic 1 o 64· Foonds o public value

Public value

Public value is the worth that a government or social-sector organization creates for citizens collectively — nae juist the ootputs it produces or the siller it spends, but whether society is better aff because the organization exists and acted as it did. Mark Moore's 1995 "strategic triangle" is the staundard test: a public initiative is justified only whan it is legitimate and supportit, substantively valuable, and operationally deliverable, aw three at ance.

Why it maitters

Private-sector value is relatively easy tae price: revenue minus cost, adjudicated by customers wha can wauk awa. Public value has nae equivalent market signal. A prison service, a tax authority, and a bairn-protection team aw produce things citizens cannae simply decline tae buy, and the "customer" (the taxpayer, the offender, the bairn) is aften nae the same person as the political principal wha authorizes the budget. Moore's Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government (Harvard University Press, 1995) supplies the missin discipline: a manager sud be able tae state (1) whit public value their initiative creates, (2) whaur their legitimacy and fundin tae pursue it comes frae — a meinister, a cooncil, a mandate, a grant — and (3) whether their organization can actually deliver it wi the fowk, technology, and processes at haund. A programme that scores weel on only ane or twa legs o the triangle isnae yet justified, hoo weel-meanin it is.

This maitters practically because maist public-sector saftware failures arenae technology failures. A system can be technically excellent and operationally deliverable and still fail because naebody in the legitimizin environment — meinisters, oversight committees, the public — actually wantit the thing it optimizes for. The Universal Credit digital service and the NHS National Programme for IT are baith citit in UK public-administration literature as cases whaur operational and legitimacy legs o the triangle were oot o step wi the mission leg.

The maths

Public value is a framework, nae a formula, but it structures itherwise-vague investment cases intae three testable questions:

Strategic triangle test — proceed only if all three hold:

1. Legitimacy and support: Who has authorized this, and does the authorizing
   environment (legislature, minister, council, board, public opinion) still
   back it as resources are committed?

2. Public value: What specific, describable good does this produce for
   citizens or society — safety, health, opportunity, trust, fairness —
   and for whom?

3. Operational capacity: Can the organization actually deliver it with
   current staff, technology, partners, and legal authority — or a
   credible plan to acquire them?

A weak initiative typically fails at least ane leg: technically deliverable but wi nae mandate (a data-sharin pilot naebody signed aff); popular but undeliverable (a promised digital service wi nae ingineerin capacity); or authorized and deliverable but value-tuim (a dashboard naebody uises).

Wrocht example

Local authority: a cooncil digital team proposes an AI triage tool for housin benefit claims.

  • Legitimacy: the cooncil's cabinet has approved a digital-first strategy, but the elected members responsible for social security hae nae signed aff automated decision-makin specifically — a gap, nae a green licht.
  • Public value: faster processin (claimit benefit: 10 days tae 2 days) is real value only if claimants arenae wrangly refused; the value claim maun include accuracy, nae juist speed.
  • Operational capacity: the cooncil has ae data scientist and nae model-monitorin process, sae the claimit 2-day turnaround isnae currently deliverable at the stated error rate.

Twa o three legs fail. Moore's framework says: dinnae proceed as scoped — first secure explicit authorization for automated decisions and big monitorin capacity, or the "public value" claimit in the business case is fictional.

Central government: a tax authority's online filin service has strong legitimacy (statutory mandate) and strong operational capacity (an existin team ships reliably) but weak public value if uptake is low because the digitally excludit — see digital inclusion — are pushed intae a channel they cannae uise. The triangle exposes whit a delivery-only dashboard wad hide.

Public value is the umbrella concept this hale repository sits unner: value for siller gies the economy/efficiency/effectiveness test for whether resources were weel uised; opportunity cost in public spendin prices whit else the siller could hae daen; and additionality and deidweicht, displacement and attribution, and coonterfactual analysis taegither test whether the claimit value is real raither nor assumed. For ingineers, the strategic triangle is a uisefu pre-mortem for ony public-sector product decision:

  • Afore scopin a feature, ask wha authorized it and whether that authorization still haulds — a feature biggit for a meinister wha has since muivit on micht hae quietly lost its legitimacy leg.
  • Treat "can we big it" and "sud we big it" as genuinely separate questions; ingineerin capacity answers only the third leg o the triangle.
  • Product requirements documents for public services sud state the public value claim explicitly, nae juist the user story, because user value and public value arenae aye the same thing (see ootcomes vs ootputs).

Pitfaws

  • Treatin operational capacity as sufficient justification. "We can big it" answers only ae leg o the triangle; teams wi strong delivery capability routinely ship things naebody authorized wantin and that create nae describable public guid.
  • Mixin up legitimacy wi legality. A programme can be lawfu and still lack the political and public support needit tae sustain it through a difficult delivery phase; legal cover isnae the same as a mandate.
  • Assumin public value is whitever the commissionin department says it is. Moore's model requires the value claim tae be testable agin citizens' actual interests, nae merely asserted by the funder — itherwise the framework collapses intae self-certification.

Sources