Topic 10 o 64· Governmental economic appraisal
Social cost-benefit analysis (SCBA)
Social cost-benefit analysis turns ilka cost an benefit o a policy or programme — merkit an non-merkit — intae a common monetary unit, discoonts future flows tae present value, an nets them aff tae mak a single nummer: daes this proposal mak society better aff, an bi hou muckle?
Why it maitters
SCBA is the default quantitative method in the economic case o Green Book appraisal: HM Treasury's guidance requires proposals tae shaw a positive net present social value (NPSV) wherever benefits can be credibly monetisit, uisin willingness-tae-pey as the basic valuation principle for non-merkit guids (https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-central-government, Chapter 5). The discipline it enforces is that "social" cost-benefit analysis isnae the same exercise as a private-sector investment appraisal: it maun include costs an benefits that fa on third pairties wha arenae pairty tae the transaction (externalities), it maun uise the social discoont rate raither nor a commercial cost o capital, an it shuid apply distributional weichtin whaur a pund maitters mair tae a puirer hoosehald nor a richer yin.
Whaur SCBA braks doun is exactly whaur its critics expect: guids wi nae merkit analogue — clean air, social cohesion, the value o a life saved — hae tae be monetisit uisin stated preference or revealed preference methods, or a shadae price haes tae be constructit. Whan monetisation is contestit raither nor juist difficult, the Green Book itsel recommends fawin back tae cost-effectiveness analysis or multi-criteria decision analysis raither nor forcin a nummer that naebody believes.
The maths
NPSV = Σ [t=0 to T] (Benefit_t − Cost_t) / (1 + r)^t
whaur:
Benefit_t = aw monetisit benefits in year t, includin non-merkit
guids valued via stated/revealed preference or shadae price
Cost_t = aw monetisit costs in year t, includin opportunity cost
o resources (see ../opportunity-cost-in-public-spending/)
r = social discoont rate (HM Treasury sets 3.5% decliniin tae
laicher rates ayont year 30, per Green Book Annex A)
T = appraisal period
Benefit-cost ratio (BCR) = Σ PV(Benefits) / Σ PV(Costs)
A BCR abuin 1 (or NPSV abuin zero) shaws net social value. The Green Book's value-for-siller categories (as uised in transport an infrastructure appraisal) label BCR ranges: ablow 1.0 is puir value for siller, 1.0–1.5 is laich, 1.5–2.0 is medium, 2.0–4.0 is high, an abuin 4.0 is very high. Sensitivity analysis — re-rinnin the NPSV unner pessimistic an optimistic assumptions — is mandatory, nae optional, acause monetisit non-merkit benefits cairry wide uncertainty bands.
Wrocht example
Local authority: a cooncil appraises a £3m investment in a new cyclin an walkin netwark ower a 20-year appraisal period at a 3.5% discoont rate.
Costs: £3m capital in year 0, £50,000/year maintenance (years 1-20)
PV(maintenance) ≈ £50,000 × 14.2 (20-year annuity factor at 3.5%) ≈ £710,000
Total PV(costs) ≈ £3.71m
Benefits (aw monetisit via publisht DfT/WHO valuation tools):
Health benefit frae increasit pheesical activity: £180,000/year
Absenteeism reduction: £40,000/year
Decongestion (fewer car trips): £60,000/year
Total benefit stream: £280,000/year
PV(benefits) ≈ £280,000 × 14.2 ≈ £3.98m
NPSV = £3.98m − £3.71m = +£0.27m
BCR = 3.98 / 3.71 = 1.07 → "laich" value for siller
The scheme clears the bar but jist aboot; a sensitivity rin at a 20% laicher health-benefit estimate (reflectin genuine uncertainty in pheesical-activity valuation) flips the BCR ablow 1.0, that is exactly why the Green Book requires the sensitivity table tae be publisht alangside the headline nummer, nae jist the central estimate.
Charity: an infant-mortality prevention programme costin £500,000/year is evaluatit uisin the value o a statistical life (VSL) — a shadae price, nae an observed merkit price — o roughly £2.1m (HM Treasury's 2023-updatit figure, itsel derived frae stated-preference studies). Avertin yin infant daith per year agin a £500,000 cost gies a BCR o 4.2, comfortably "very high" value for siller — but the hail result rests on the VSL figure, that is why ony SCBA uisin VSL maun disclose it as an assumption, nae a fact.
Link tae saftware ingineerin
SCBA is the natural frame for platform an infrastructure investment decisions in government saftware — comparin a shared identity platform agin depairtmental pynt solutions, for instance, requires monetisin benefits like reducit duplicate onboardin cost, reducit fraud, an quicker time-tae-service that hae nae merkit price on their ain. Engineers biggin the underlyin service shuid expect programme leads tae ask for inputs tae this analysis: unit costs o transactions (see cost per transaction), expectit volumes, an degradation/doun-time costs. The discipline that maitters maist tae import: discoont future benefits, name the counterfactual baseline explicitly (see counterfactual analysis), an never present a single pynt estimate athoot its sensitivity range.
Pitfaws
- Double-coontin benefits. Coontin baith "time saved" an "productivity gained frae that time" as separate benefit lines owerstates the case; time saved is the benefit, its doun-stream uise isnae an extra yin unless independently evidenced.
- Leavin oot displacit costs. A scheme that muives congestion frae yin road tae anither, or muives fraud frae yin channel tae anither, haesnae creatit the net benefit its headline NPSV implies — see displacement an attribution.
- Uisin a private discoont rate. Applyin a commercial cost o capital (say 8–10%) insteid o the social discoont rate systematically unnervalues lang-horizon public benefits like health an environmental gains — see social discoont rate.
- Monetisin the uncontestit an hand-wavin the contestit. If twa-thirds o a proposal's benefit is a confidently monetisit efficiency savin an yin-third is a shakily monetisit wellbein gain, the headline NPSV quietly blends a hard nummer wi a saft yin; report them separately.
Sources
- HM Treasury. "The Green Book: appraisal and evaluation in central government." 2022, Chapter 5. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-central-government
- HM Treasury. "Green Book supplementary guidance: value of a statistical life." 2023. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/green-book-supplementary-guidance-value-of-a-statistical-life
- Department for Transport. "TAG unit A1.1: cost-benefit analysis." Transport Analysis Guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/transport-analysis-guidance-tag