Topic 3 o 64· Foonds o public value

Opportunity cost in public spendin

Opportunity cost is the value o the best alternative forgone whan a public body commits siller, staff time, or political capital tae ae option insteid o anither. In a department wi a fixed budget, ilka pund spent on ae programme is a pund that cannae be spent on the next-best programme — the true cost o a decision isnae whit it spends, but whit it displaces.

Why it maitters

Public budgets are cash-limitit within a spendin review period, sae — unlike a growin private firm — a government department cannae juist "find mair siller" for a guid idea; fundin it means un-fundin somethin else. HM Treasury's Green Book (the Treasury's appraisal guidance) treats this as foundational: ilka appraisal is requirt tae compare an intervention agin a "do minimum" baseline and agin realistic alternative uises o the same resource, juist because the real question a Treasury spendin team asks is never "is this guid?" but "is this better nor whit else this siller could buy?" The Green Book's core appraisal principle — that public resources sud flow tae the intervention wi the heichest net social value per pund — is opportunity cost stated as policy.

This is easy tae state and hard tae apply because the "next-best alternative" is raurly veisible in a single business case. A £2 million grant programme for youth employment is compared, in the business case, agin daein naething — but the honest comparator is the next-best youth employment intervention, or indeed the next-best uise o £2 million onywhaur in the portfolio, includin non-employment spendin. The Magenta Book (HM Treasury, 2020) warns explicitly that evaluations comparin "with intervention" tae "without intervention" understate the bar an intervention maun clear, because "without this intervention" isnae the same as "with naething at aw" — siller released funds somethin else.

The maths

Opportunity cost of choosing A = value of the best forgone alternative B

Net public value of A = value(A) − value(B), not value(A) − 0

There is nae universal formula because the forgone alternative is context-specific, but the discipline generalizes: identify the realistic next-best uise o the same budget line (nae an idealized "dae naething"), value it on the same basis (monetized whaur possible, per social cost-benefit analysis), and subtract.

Wrocht example

Department budget line: a £5 million digital-transformation fund can finance exactly ane o twa proposals this financial year.

  • Option A: a new case-management platform, monetized benefit £7.2 million ower 5 year (efficiency savings plus faster case resolution).
  • Option B: an identity-verification service shared across three departments, monetized benefit £6.4 million ower 5 year.

A naïve business case for A compares £7.2 million o benefit agin £5 million o cost and reports a 1.44:1 benefit-cost ratio — apparently strong. But because A and B compete for the same £5 million, the opportunity cost o choosin A is B's £6.4 million forgone benefit. The net case for A ower the realistic alternative is only £7.2m − £6.4m = £0.8 million, nae the fu £7.2 million headline. If a third option, C, offered £7.5 million o benefit for the same £5 million, fundin A ower C wad destroy £0.3 million o public value even though A's ain business case looks fully justified in isolation.

Local authority staff time: a cooncil's three-person data team can big either a housin-waitlist dashboard (estimatit tae save 400 officer-hours/year, valued at £28/hour = £11,200/year) or a benefits-fraud triage tool (estimatit tae prevent £85,000/year in incorrect payments). Biggin the dashboard has an opportunity cost o £85,000/year forgone, nae merely the salary cost o the data team — the real cost o the "free" internal build is the faur larger benefit the team could hae produced elsewhaur.

Ingineerin capacity inside a public body is itsel a constrained budget — sprint capacity, nae punds — and the same discipline applies directly:

  • Aye name the comparator: a feature's business case sud state whit else the same team-weeks could deliver, nae juist its ain return.
  • Treat "we hae ingineerin capacity spare" as the stairt o an opportunity-cost analysis, nae the end — spare capacity still has a best alternative uise, even if that uise is technical-debt paydoun (see technical debt as public value erosion).
  • Connect this directly tae value for siller: VFM's "economy" test is meaninless wioot an honest opportunity-cost comparator, and tae cost o delay in public programmes, which prices the time dimension o the same forgone-alternative logic.

Pitfaws

  • Comparin agin "dae naething" insteid o the next-best alternative. The Green Book requires a "do minimum" baseline juist because true opportunity cost is raurly zero; a business case that only clears the "dae naething" bar has nae shown it beats the realistic alternative.
  • Ignorin cross-departmental competition for the same pot. Budget lines that look ring-fenced within ae directorate aften compete at a heicher level (a spendin review, a capital programme) whaur the real opportunity cost is realized.
  • Assumin staff time released has nae further value. Time "saved" only creates value if redeployed tae somethin valuable; if the alternative uise disnae exist, the savin is notional.

Sources