Topic 52 o 64· Wellbein, equity an societal indicators
Wellbein-adjustit life years (WELLBY)
A WELLBY is yin extra pynt o life satisfaction, on the staundard 0–10 wellbein scale, for yin person for yin year. It is the structural analogue o the QALY uised in health economics — a single unit that lets ye compare interventions whase ootcomes hae naethin else in common — but biggit on subjective wellbein raither nor clinical health states, an set oot in HM Treasury's "Wellbeing guidance for appraisal: supplementary Green Book guidance" (2021).
Why it maitters
Cost-benefit appraisal needs a common unit tae compare a youth-club grant agin a road-safety scheme agin a mental-health service, nane o that share an ootcome meisure. Health economics solved this for clinical interventions wi the QALY: a quality-adjustit year o life, weichtit frae 0 (deid) tae 1 (full health). HM Treasury's wellbein guidance extends the same logic tae non-health public spendin, uisin the ONS's harmonised life-satisfaction question ("Overall, how satisfied are you with your life nowadays?", answered 0–10) as the ootcome ladder insteid o a health-state index. A WELLBY o 1 means yin person's life satisfaction risin bi yin full pynt for yin year (or, equivalently, ten fowk's satisfaction risin bi 0.1 pynt each for a year — WELLBYs sum athort a population the wey QALYs dae). HM Treasury's guidance sets an illustrative monetary value per WELLBY (aboot £13,000, 2019/20 prices) derived bi reconcilin subjective-wellbein data wi ither approaches tae the value o a life year, gien appraisers a wey tae monetise ootcomes — lonelieness reduction, community cohesion, green-space access — that wellbein valuation techniques could previously ainly describe, nae compare on a common fittin wi health or safety spendin.
The maths
WELLBY = Δ life satisfaction (0–10 scale) × nummer o years the chynge persists
(summed athort aw fowk affectit)
Monetisit wellbein benefit = WELLBYs generatit × value per WELLBY (HMT reference value)
cf. QALY = Δ health-state utility (0–1 scale) × years liveit in that state
The 0–10 satisfaction scale an the 0–1 QALY utility scale arenae interchangeable athoot a conversion step; HM Treasury's guidance discusses reconcilin the twa sae that, for example, a health intervention appraised in QALYs an a social intervention appraised in WELLBYs arenae quietly double-coontit or left incomparable inside the same Green Book appraisal.
Wrocht example
Local authority lonelieness service: a befriendin scheme serves 400 isolatit aulder residents. Follae-up surveys shaw average life satisfaction rises frae 5.2 tae 6.0 (a gain o 0.8 pynts), an the effect is estimatit tae persist for 2 years afore fadin.
WELLBYs = 400 people × 0.8 points × 2 years = 640 WELLBYs
Monetisit value = 640 × £13,000 = £8,320,000
Agin an annual programme cost o £300,000 (£600,000 ower 2 years), the benefit-cost ratio is roughly 8,320,000 / 600,000 ≈ 13.9:1 — a figure that can nou sit in the same appraisal table as a health scheme's cost-per-QALY-avertit or a transport scheme's journey-time savins.
Charity, smawer scale: a community arts programme reaches 50 participants wi a meisurit satisfaction gain o 0.3 pynts, lastin 1 year.
WELLBYs = 50 × 0.3 × 1 = 15 WELLBYs
Monetisit value = 15 × £13,000 = £195,000
Link tae saftware ingineerin
- Ony citizen-facin service that aareadies collects a life-satisfaction or wellbein survey item (mony local-authority an health-an-care platforms dae, follaein ONS's fower staundard wellbein questions) can compute WELLBYs directly frae existin data pipelines raither nor commissionin bespoke economic evaluation for ilka service chynge.
- WELLBYs gie engineerin teams biggin for social value act reportin or social return on investment a nationally staundardised, HM-Treasury-endorsed denominator, avoidin the proliferation o bespoke "impact scores" that cannae be compared athort contracts or suppliers.
- Acause WELLBYs are additive athort fowk an time, they compose cleanly intae the kind o population-level ootcome trackin uised in ootcomes-based accoontability systems — a service dashboard can report cumulative WELLBYs generatit per quarter the wey a health system reports QALYs gained.
Pitfaws
- Assumin self-reportit satisfaction gains are entirely attributable tae the intervention — athoot a coonterfactual (comparison group or before/efter design wi controls), ye cannae separate the WELLBY gain frae general trends; see coonterfactual analysis.
- Mixin WELLBYs an QALYs in yin total athoot reconciliation — HM Treasury's guidance is explicit that the twa uise different scales an different underlyin theories o value; summin them naively double-coonts owerlappin welfare.
- Uisin the reference monetary value uncritically — the £-per-WELLBY figure is a national average estimate wi real uncertainty bands; HM Treasury guidance recommends sensitivity analysis, nae treatin it as a fixed exchange rate.
Sources
- HM Treasury. "Wellbeing guidance for appraisal: supplementary Green Book guidance." (2021) https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/wellbeing-guidance-for-appraisal-supplementary-green-book-guidance
- ONS. "Personal well-being user guidance" (the four standard wellbeing questions). https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/wellbeing
- HM Treasury. "The Green Book: Central Government Guidance on Appraisal and Evaluation."