第 26 个主题,共 64 个· 政府绩效搭交付指标
公共价值计分卡
公共价值计分卡拿 Robert Kaplan 搭 David Norton 1992 年提出个平衡计分卡改编过来——原来是为企业设计个,勒财务、客户、内部流程、学习与成长四个视角上优化利润——现在用勒底线是使命而勿是利润率个机构。伊逼公共机构同时勒好几个勿可压缩个维度上汇报绩效,而勿是拿一切折成一个数字,拿权衡取舍藏起来。
为啥重要
Kaplan 搭 Norton 勒《哈佛商业评论》里厢个原始论点是:单个财务指标是滞后指标,伊勿会告诉侬下一季度个绩效为啥会变。私营部门个解法是四个相互关联个视角。勒政府里厢,Mark Moore 个“战略三角”(出自《Creating Public Value》,1995)提供了对应个结构:一项服务必须同时交付公共价值(使命成果)、维持合法性搭支持(政治搭公众个支持)、并且运营上可行(凭实际有个资源搭能力交付得了)。Paul Niven 个《Balanced Scorecard: Step-by-Step for Government and Nonprofit Agencies》(2003)是拿 Kaplan 搭 Norton 个四个格子翻译成搿个三角个实践手册——通常是拿“财务”重新标成“资源个管家责任”,拿“使命”放勒顶上而勿是拿“股东价值”放勒底下,并且拿客户搭利益相关方视角看作平等个,而勿是附属于利润。对交付团队来讲,搿个要紧,是因为一项只用财务或者效率指标(比如单笔交易成本)来评判个公共数字服务,会系统性地对合法性搭成果维度投入不足,而搿些维度是财务指标看勿见个。
数学
公共价值计分卡是个框架,勿是公式,但是伊个结构是固定个,值得原样重现:
Perspective Public-sector question Example indicator
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mission / outcomes Are we achieving the public value we Population outcome measure
exist to create? (see outcomes-vs-outputs)
Stewardship of Are we using public money efficiently Cost per outcome, budget
resources and within authorized limits? variance
Customer / user Are users and citizens able to access Completion rate, satisfaction
and benefit from the service?
Legitimacy / support Do political principals, oversight Trust metrics, audit findings,
bodies, and the public still back us? complaints upheld
Internal process / Do we have the capability and process Staff turnover, cycle time,
learning to keep improving? backlog age
A defensible scorecard reports 3–5 indicators per perspective, chosen so that
no single perspective can be gamed without the damage showing up in another.
实例演算
地方政府成人社会照护部门:一项康复促进服务(短期支持,帮助人拉住院之后恢复自理能力)个计分卡汇报:
Mission: 68% of service users no longer need ongoing care after 6 weeks (target 65%)
Stewardship: cost per completed reablement episode = £1,850 (budget assumption £2,000)
Customer: user satisfaction 82%, average wait for service start 4.1 days
Legitimacy: 3 upheld complaints per 1,000 episodes; adult safeguarding board rates
service "good"
Process: staff vacancy rate 14%, average caseload 23 (safe caseload ceiling: 25)
单独看,使命搭资源管家两栏个数字像是一个直截了当个成功故事:低于预算、高于成果目标。搭流程一行一道看,14% 个空缺率对 25 个个案量上限,说明好个成果是靠接近勿安全个人手水平换来个——搿个警告,单看使命数字永远发现勿了,恰恰是单一视角 KPI(参见公共部门 KPI)招来个失效模式。
搭软件工程个关联
对一个做内部或者面向公众仪表盘个团队来讲,计分卡直接反对做一个单一个“健康分”组件:每个视角一块面板,勿要顶着产品压力拿伊拉综合成一盏红绿灯,因为综合个步骤恰恰是权衡信息被毁脱个地方。伊也可以清清爽爽对应产品团队个 OKR 结构:一个使命 OKR 倘使呒没配对个资源管家或者流程 OKR,就重现了 Kaplan 搭 Norton 1992 年写文章时反对个单一指标失效模式。参见公共价值了解 Moore 关于“使命”一格到底该装啥个底层理论,参见信任搭合法性指标了解怎样用真实、有出处个指标,而勿是一个呒没人辩护得了个代理指标,来填充合法性视角。
容易踏个坑
- 拿计分卡压成一个分数:拿四个视角平均成一个数字,就重新带回了计分卡本来要防止个问题——差个合法性得分被好个资源管家得分掩盖。
- 原封勿动照搬私营部门个“财务”视角:公共机构个资源管家视角讲个是守勒授权个、往往专款专用个预算之内,而勿是收入最大化——Niven 个重新标注勿只是表面功夫。
- 选了拥有计分卡个团队自己就能单方面拨动个指标:合法性指标倘使来自伊所评判个同一个团队(比如自我汇报个投诉处理),就勿是独立个证据。
- 计分卡做一次就再勿重新审视权重搭指标:Kaplan 搭 Norton 本意是每年做一次战略审视;一张冻结好几年个计分卡,会渐渐偏离伊本来要追踪个使命。
资料来源
- Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton, "The Balanced Scorecard: Measures That Drive Performance," Harvard Business Review, January–February 1992.
- Paul R. Niven, Balanced Scorecard: Step-by-Step for Government and Nonprofit Agencies, Wiley, 2003.
- Mark H. Moore, Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government, Harvard University Press, 1995.