第 46 个主题,共 64 个· 数字政府里个公共价值
开放数据个价值
开放数据个价值,讲个是一个问题:政府搭公共数据勿卖钞票,呒没收入一栏,价值到底值多少?但是伊拉放出来(天气记录、交通时刻表、邮编边界、公司登记册),下游确实会带出经济搭社会活动。要估好搿个价值是要紧个,因为“放出来勿要花钞票”搭“一钿勿值”两种讲法才是错个,软件工程师要决定开勿开一个 API 或者数据集,需要比搿两种讲法更好个论据。
为啥重要
引用最多个自上而下估算,来自麦肯锡全球研究院 2013 年个报告《Open data: Unlocking innovation and performance with liquid information》,伊估计开放数据勒七个领域——教育、交通、消费品、电力、油气、医疗搭消费金融——全球每年个潜在价值是 3 万亿到 5 万亿美元,机制包括提高透明度、更有效地匹配供需,搭催生基于数据个新产品搭新服务。搿个数字是情景估算,勿是实测出来个结果,常常被错误地引用,好像是政府可以直接拿到手个收入;实际上价值大多落勒第三方——企业、研究者、市民——用数据个人身上,搿恰恰就是开放而勿是出售个意义所在。英国开放数据研究所(Open Data Institute)2012 年由 Tim Berners-Lee 爵士搭 Nigel Shadbolt 爵士联合创办,之后积累了一批更细致、自下而上个案例研究——一个行业一个行业、一个数据集一个数据集地做——对真正个商业方案比麦肯锡个标题数字有用得多,因为伊拉展示了价值创造个机制,而勿光是总体规模。
数学
开放数据呒没市场价格,所以要用估值方法来替代;常用三种办法,单靠一种都勿够:
1. Cost-avoided / replacement-cost method:
value ≈ what users would have paid to produce or licence the
equivalent data themselves — a lower bound, ignores value created
by uses the original producer never anticipated
2. Market-analogue / downstream-activity method:
value ≈ revenue or savings generated by businesses/services built
on the data (e.g. satnav apps built on open mapping and traffic
data) — captures real economic activity but is hard to attribute
cleanly to the data release itself (see additionality-and-deadweight)
3. Contingent/stated-preference method:
value ≈ what users say they would pay, or the time they say it
saves them — see stated-preference-valuation for the general
method and its biases
None of these produces a figure as clean as a market price; credible
open data business cases triangulate across two or more, and are
explicit about which mechanism is doing the work.
实例演算
示例性个全国地图/地址数据开放(方法参照 ODI 风格个案例研究,数字只是示意此类研究通常得出个量级):
Cost-avoided estimate:
Businesses that would otherwise licence equivalent address-matching
data commercially, at an estimated average licence cost of £4,000/
year, across an estimated 15,000 SMEs now using the free open dataset
= 15,000 × £4,000 = £60,000,000/year in avoided licensing cost alone
Downstream-activity estimate (more speculative, needs a counterfactual):
New delivery-routing and logistics products built on the open data
that would not exist, or would be materially worse, without it —
requires a comparison against the counterfactual of the data staying
closed or commercially licensed (counterfactual-analysis), because
some of that activity would happen anyway on paid data at a higher
price, which is deadweight in the "value created by opening it" sense
A defensible business case reports the cost-avoided figure as the
solid lower bound, and treats the downstream-activity figure as an
upper-bound scenario, not a fact.
搭软件工程个关联
对工程师来讲,开放数据价值个实际问题通常比全国性个标题数字要窄:开放搿个具体个 API 或者数据集(而勿是继续放勒合作协议后头),能勿能带来足够多个复用,值得为伊作为公共接口去编写文档、做版本管理、持续支持个长期成本?搿笔维护成本是真个,搭政府即平台“一次建设、多次复用”个经济账是配对个——两个主题是近亲,一个讲共享代码搭基础设施,另一个讲共享数据。任何开放数据价值个主张,写进商业方案之前,应该对照增量搭无谓损失检查一遍:勒商业授权数据上本来就会发生个活动,勿是开放创造出来个价值。
容易踏个坑
- 拿麦肯锡个 3–5 万亿美元当成英国专属数字,或者当成某个数据集个份额:搿是 2013 年个全球七个行业个情景估算——拿伊当单个国家数据集个精确乘数,就误解了搿个数字是啥。
- 呒没反事实:拿基于开放数据个全部下游经济活动才算勒自家功劳,却勿问其中有多少勒付费或者授权数据上、以更高价格本来也会发生(参见增量搭无谓损失搭反事实分析)。
- 拿生产成本搭创造个价值混为一谈:一个收集起来老贵个数据集,放出来勿一定有价值;一个便宜个,也勿一定价值低——价值跟下游使用走,勿跟上游成本走。
- 忽视“开放”个持续维护成本:发布一份一次性个 CSV 导出搭运营一个有文档、有版本、有支持个开放 API,承诺完全勿是一回事——发布公告之后对后者经费勿足,是常见个失败模式。
资料来源
- McKinsey Global Institute, "Open data: Unlocking innovation and performance with liquid information" (2013). https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/open-data-unlocking-innovation-and-performance-with-liquid-information
- Open Data Institute. https://theodi.org/