第 46 個主題,共 64 個· 數碼政府嘅公共價值
開放數據嘅價值
開放數據價值,係指喺冇價錢嘅情況下,點樣估算政府同公共數據值幾多錢:呢啲數據唔會出售,所以冇收入項目,但將佢哋公開(天氣記錄、交通時間表、郵編邊界、公司登記冊),明顯會喺下游帶動經濟同社會活動。評估得好至關重要,因為「公開唔使錢」同「毫無價值」兩種講法都唔正確,而決定要唔要開放某個 API 或者數據集嘅軟件工程師,需要比呢兩種講法更有力嘅論據。
點解重要
被引用最多嘅由上而下估算,來自 McKinsey Global Institute 2013 年報告《Open data: Unlocking innovation and performance with liquid information》,該報告估計開放數據喺七個範疇——教育、交通、消費品、電力、石油及天然氣、醫療保健同消費金融——嘅潛在年度價值,全球達每年 $3 trillion(3 萬億)至 $5 trillion(5 萬億),途徑包括提高透明度、更有效率咁配對供求,以及令基於數據嘅新產品同服務得以出現。呢個數字係情景估算,而唔係實際量度到嘅成果,亦經常被誤引為政府可以直接取得嘅收入;事實上價值主要由第三方——企業、研究人員、市民——使用數據而獲得,而呢點正正就係公開而非出售嘅意義所在。英國嘅 Open Data Institute 由 Sir Tim Berners-Lee 同 Sir Nigel Shadbolt 於 2012 年共同創辦,其後累積咗一批更細緻、由下而上嘅個案研究——逐個行業、逐個數據集——比 McKinsey 嘅頭條數字更適用於真實嘅商業個案,因為佢哋展示咗價值創造嘅機制,而不只係總體規模。
數學原理
開放數據冇市場價格,所以要用估值方法代替;常見有三種做法,冇一種可以單獨足夠:
1. Cost-avoided / replacement-cost method:
value ≈ what users would have paid to produce or licence the
equivalent data themselves — a lower bound, ignores value created
by uses the original producer never anticipated
2. Market-analogue / downstream-activity method:
value ≈ revenue or savings generated by businesses/services built
on the data (e.g. satnav apps built on open mapping and traffic
data) — captures real economic activity but is hard to attribute
cleanly to the data release itself (see additionality-and-deadweight)
3. Contingent/stated-preference method:
value ≈ what users say they would pay, or the time they say it
saves them — see stated-preference-valuation for the general
method and its biases
None of these produces a figure as clean as a market price; credible
open data business cases triangulate across two or more, and are
explicit about which mechanism is doing the work.
實例演算
說明用嘅全國地圖/地址數據公開(方法仿照 ODI 式個案研究,數字用以說明此類研究一般得出嘅規模):
Cost-avoided estimate:
Businesses that would otherwise licence equivalent address-matching
data commercially, at an estimated average licence cost of £4,000/
year, across an estimated 15,000 SMEs now using the free open dataset
= 15,000 × £4,000 = £60,000,000/year in avoided licensing cost alone
Downstream-activity estimate (more speculative, needs a counterfactual):
New delivery-routing and logistics products built on the open data
that would not exist, or would be materially worse, without it —
requires a comparison against the counterfactual of the data staying
closed or commercially licensed (counterfactual-analysis), because
some of that activity would happen anyway on paid data at a higher
price, which is deadweight in the "value created by opening it" sense
A defensible business case reports the cost-avoided figure as the
solid lower bound, and treats the downstream-activity figure as an
upper-bound scenario, not a fact.
與軟件工程嘅關係
對工程師嚟講,開放數據價值嘅實際問題,通常比全國頭條數字狹窄得多:開放呢個特定 API 或者數據集(而唔係鎖喺夥伴協議後面),會唔會增加足夠嘅重用,去抵銷將佢作為公共介面來撰寫文件、版本管理同提供支援嘅持續成本?呢項維護成本係真實存在,亦係政府即平台「一次建成、多次重用」經濟學嘅對應面——兩個題目係近親,一個講共享程式碼同基礎設施,另一個講共享數據。任何開放數據價值嘅聲稱,納入商業個案之前,都應該對照額外性與死重效應檢查:就算冇開放,一樣會喺商業授權數據上發生嘅活動,唔係開放所創造嘅價值。
常見陷阱
- 將 McKinsey 嘅 $3–5 trillion(3–5 萬億美元)當作英國專屬,或者當作某個數據集嘅份額:呢個係 2013 年全球、七個行業嘅情景估算——將佢當作單一國家數據集嘅精確乘數,就曲解咗呢個數字嘅本質。
- 冇反事實:將所有建基於開放數據嘅下游經濟活動都歸功於開放,卻冇問過其中幾多本來都會喺付費或者授權數據上、以更高價錢發生(見額外性與死重效應同反事實分析)。
- 混淆生產成本同創造價值:收集成本高昂嘅數據集,唔會自動就值得公開;成本低廉嘅,亦唔會自動價值低——價值跟隨下游使用,而唔係上游成本。
- 忽略「開放」嘅持續維護成本:發佈一次性 CSV 匯出,同營運一個有文件、有版本管理、有支援嘅開放 API,承諾完全唔同——發佈公告之後就削減後者經費,係常見嘅失敗模式。
資料來源
- McKinsey Global Institute, "Open data: Unlocking innovation and performance with liquid information" (2013). https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/open-data-unlocking-innovation-and-performance-with-liquid-information
- Open Data Institute. https://theodi.org/