Topic 4 of 64· Public value foundations
Social Discount Rate
The social discount rate converts future costs and benefits into present-day values so that programmes with payoffs spread across decades can be compared on a common basis. HM Treasury's Green Book mandates a declining schedule anchored at 3.5% for the first 30 years, based on the Ramsey formula — a specific, citable number that has become a live political and ethical argument whenever it is applied to long-horizon commitments such as climate policy or infrastructure.
Why it matters
A pound of benefit received in 30 years is not worth a pound of benefit received today, for reasons that are partly about pure time preference (people and societies prefer good things sooner) and partly about growth (a future society is expected to be richer, so a pound matters less to it at the margin). The Green Book's Annex 6 derives the UK's standard discount rate from the Ramsey formula, combining a rate of pure time preference with the expected growth rate of consumption and the elasticity of marginal utility of consumption, producing the published rate of 3.5% per year for years 0–30, declining in a published schedule for years 31 and beyond (down to 1% for years 301+). This schedule exists precisely because a constant 3.5% compounded over a century would make virtually any long-horizon benefit — a flood defence saving lives in 80 years, a carbon reduction avoiding harm in 100 years — appear negligible in present-value terms, which the Treasury judged to be an implausible ethical conclusion for genuinely long-lived infrastructure and environmental decisions.
The discount rate is contested precisely because the choice is not a neutral technical parameter: it encodes a judgement about how much a society should sacrifice today for people not yet born. The Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change (2006) used a discount rate close to zero (a pure time preference near 0.1%), arguing that discounting future generations' welfare at anything like market rates is ethically indefensible when the harm (catastrophic climate change) is irreversible. Critics — notably William Nordhaus — argued Stern's near-zero rate overstated the case for immediate climate spending by making almost any present cost look justified against a barely-discounted future benefit. The disagreement was not about the maths; it was about whose ethical framework should set the rate, and it remains the standard illustration of why the discount rate is a policy choice, not just an actuarial input.
The maths
The Ramsey formula underlying the Green Book's rate:
r = ρ + η·g
where:
r = social discount rate
ρ = rate of pure time preference (impatience + catastrophe risk)
η = elasticity of marginal utility of consumption
g = expected annual growth rate of per-capita consumption
The Green Book's declining schedule (Annex 6, illustrative — check the current edition for the exact published table):
Years 0–30: 3.5%
Years 31–75: 3.0%
Years 76–125: 2.5%
Years 126–200: 2.0%
Years 201–300: 1.5%
Years 301+: 1.0%
Present value of a future sum:
PV = FV / (1 + r)^t
Worked example
Flood defence scheme: a project delivers £10 million of avoided flood damage in year 40.
Using a flat 3.5% rate: PV = 10,000,000 / (1.035)^40 ≈ £2.52 million — the benefit looks small.
Using the Green Book's declining schedule (3.5% for years 0–30, 3.0% thereafter), the calculation compounds at 3.5% for the first 30 years and 3.0% for years 31–40:
PV = 10,000,000 / [(1.035)^30 × (1.03)^10]
= 10,000,000 / [2.807 × 1.344]
≈ 10,000,000 / 3.773
≈ £2.65 million
The declining schedule modestly raises the present value of long-horizon benefits relative to a flat high rate — the explicit purpose of the schedule, since a flat 3.5% for a century would discount a £100 million benefit in year 100 to under £3.3 million.
Digital infrastructure: a government cloud migration costing £4 million now is expected to avoid £500,000/year in legacy maintenance costs for 15 years. At 3.5%, the present value of that annuity is approximately £500,000 × 11.52 (the 15-year annuity factor at 3.5%) ≈ £5.76 million — comfortably exceeding the £4 million cost, a positive net present value case that would look markedly weaker at a naively chosen higher rate (at 7%, the same annuity factor drops to about 9.11, giving £4.56 million, still positive but with a much thinner margin).
Software engineering connection
Most software business cases run over 3–5 years, well inside the flat 3.5% band, so the declining schedule rarely bites directly — but the underlying discipline matters for any government technology investment with a long asset life (a national platform, a data infrastructure programme, a multi-decade contract):
- Use the Green Book's published rate rather than an internal "hurdle rate" borrowed from private finance; auditors and Treasury reviewers will expect the standard schedule.
- For benefits realized many years out (a platform's long-term maintenance savings, an open-data ecosystem's compounding value — see open data value), the discounting choice can flip a business case from positive to negative; make the rate and horizon explicit assumptions, not buried defaults.
- This feeds directly into green-book-appraisal, the five-case model that formally requires a discounted cash flow, and into wellbeing-valuation, where the same discounting question arises for non-monetary wellbeing benefits.
- See also intergenerational equity and sustainability discounting for the Stern-versus-Nordhaus debate applied specifically to environmental and climate technology investment.
Pitfalls
- Using a flat rate for very long horizons. The Green Book's declining schedule exists specifically because a constant rate understates genuinely long-lived benefits; check which band applies rather than defaulting to 3.5% throughout.
- Treating the discount rate as ethically neutral. The Stern-Nordhaus dispute shows the rate encodes a value judgement about future generations; changing it changes which programmes look justified, so it should be stated and defended, not hidden in a spreadsheet default.
- Confusing the social discount rate with a private cost of capital. Government borrowing costs and private-sector hurdle rates are different concepts from the Ramsey-derived social rate, and substituting one for the other in a public appraisal will typically distort the result in the direction of favouring short-term returns.
- Discounting real and nominal cash flows inconsistently. The Green Book rate is a real (inflation- adjusted) rate; discounting nominal cash flows with it materially understates present values.
Sources
- HM Treasury, "The Green Book: Central Government Guidance on Appraisal and Evaluation", Annex 6 (2022). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-central-government
- Stern N. "The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review." HM Treasury, 2006.
- Nordhaus WD. "A Review of the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change." Journal of Economic Literature, 2007;45(3):686–702.
- Ramsey FP. "A Mathematical Theory of Saving." Economic Journal, 1928;38(152):543–559.